Yes — holiday pay is a frequent source of employment disputes, particularly where commission forms a substantial part of an employee’s earnings.
A useful illustration is Smart v Hidden Hearing Ltd (DWT0516 [2005] E.L.R. 367), which was heard before the Labour Court. The employee argued that his holiday pay had been calculated incorrectly. He maintained that it should have been based on his current earnings, including commission, rather than basic salary alone.
The employer relied on S.I. No. 475/1997 – Organisation of Working Time (Determination of Pay for Holidays) Regulations, 1997, made under the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997, and contended that the holiday pay had been calculated correctly.
How Is Holiday Pay Calculated?
Under Regulation 3 of the 1997 Regulations:
Where pay does not vary (for example, where an employee is paid a fixed salary or time rate), holiday pay is based on the normal weekly rate of pay last worked before the annual leave begins. Regular bonuses or allowances that do not fluctuate are included, but overtime is excluded.
Where pay fluctuates (for example, where commission forms part of earnings), holiday pay must be calculated based on the average weekly pay over the previous 13 weeks, excluding overtime.
In Smart, the Labour Court confirmed that where earnings fluctuate due to commission, Regulation 3(3) applies. Accordingly, the employee’s holiday pay was to be calculated by reference to his average earnings over the relevant 13-week period.
Why This Matters for Employers
The legislation governing working time and holiday pay is detailed and technical. Errors can easily arise, particularly where remuneration structures include commission, bonuses, or variable payments.
Misapplying the Regulations may result in a complaint to the Workplace Relations Commission or an appeal to the Labour Court.
For employers, the key takeaway is clear:
Identify whether pay is fixed or variable.
Apply the correct calculation method under the Regulations.
Keep accurate payroll records to support the calculation used.
Careful compliance with the statutory framework under the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997 helps minimise the risk of costly and time-consuming disputes.
FT Consultants – Your Partner in Navigating the Future of Work
For help and support contact us at FT Consultants today for all your workplace needs.
Share this post: